Skip to main content

Education: Letting Every Child See The Light

This is a different post than I typically share. This is actually a short journal entry I shared for my current course. Yes, I am back in classes pursing my PhD and yes, I need there to be more hours in the day. Thought I'd share since my thoughts are constantly drifting to both of my boys. 



The hardest thing about my son’s diagnosis to accept was the cognitive side of Down syndrome. It is not easy to swallow the words mental retardation that accompany the diagnosis. Especially for a person who has spent her life believing that people have ability and it simply comes down to the ability to apply one’s self. To realize that the future and the potential for Kaleb is unknown is scary. Still it is hard not to allow children with special needs like my Kaleb to penetrate my thoughts as I read the different theories on the purpose and philosophy of education. To examine what does education mean for children like Kaleb? Things such as Aristotle’s view that everything continues to changes as it works and moves towards what it was intended to become (Cathorn, 2002). These ideas begin to take on new meaning as I wonder if this holds true with Down syndrome. It can be enough on a bad day to make you want to question the verse, ‘fearfully and wonderfully made,’ (Psalms 139:14).

So I began to look at the readings from the sense of how am I to educate Kaleb, be an advocate for him, and educate others on how to educate him. Hinchey (2008) spends time explaining much of what we do is rooted in our beliefs, meaning it is because that is how it has always been done. She explains, ‘What we do usually has its roots in what we believe, and beliefs are not the unshakable foundation for action we usually assume,’ (p. 2). The past belief was that those with Down syndrome were unable to learn. Current day individuals with Down syndrome show that this isn’t true, especially with the aid of early intervention. Children with Down syndrome do not historically test well in IQ tests so they are labeled with anywhere from mild to severe cognitive delays. Now that we are constantly seeing that they can and do learn. So now we have to examine how do we teach, and should they use the same methods and have the same goals as that of other typical children? I love where Hinchey talks about that through the lens of critical theory we are able to refocus our vision and it allows us to open our minds to possibilities once found unfathomable. Merleau-Ponty is referenced as explaining that true philosophy is about relearning how we look at the world (Feinberg, n.a.). 

It makes me go back to Plato’s views of sight and the light. Plato explained that sight might exist, that colors, shapes, and patterns be present but one main component to put it altogether is critical for without it the sight will see nothing and everything present will go unseen. This component is light. Plato later goes on to say that education takes for granted that the sight is there, that it already exists. Its goal is to simply redirect it by adding the light. Sure, educators, parents, therapists, and doctors may have to find alternative methods of redirecting so that the light shines and the sight is able to see the beautiful colors, vibrant patterns, and various shapes. It is all about finding methods that work for each child. While we might not execute it very effectively in education, most would acknowledge that education is not a one size fits all. It is about finding what works for each child; what learning styles work best, how to incorporate the various levels of thinking and application, and which teaching style are best to utilize and when.

Those such as Lawrence as referenced by Standish (2005) believe that education is to lead the individual to reaching his or her true fullness. I find myself wondering if they hold true to their beliefs if it is someone besides a typical developing individual. Perhaps they might hold more to Neill’s view referenced by Standish which believe that the purpose of education is to make people happier, more secure, and less prejudiced. Even if a person has trouble swallowing that those same principles apply I would say that perhaps it is because they see the main goal of education as being of the purpose to serve the economy. I would then challenge them that if that is the case the same would hold true for someone with Down syndrome. If the sole purpose and philosophy of education is to prepare individuals to be productive members of society then again why would we not work to find ways to allow those with this diagnosis to do just that, to contribute to their communities and to the world? Individuals with Down syndrome are continuously showing they can do just that. Some are starting their own businesses, acting, modeling, being public speakers, marrying, and many other things once thought impossible. These things are things that most would consider the basis of being productive citizens. So if that is the case, if it is simply a matter of working to find alternative ways and methods to help redirect their sight, to help shine the light why would we not do just that? I’ll conclude with a quote from Hinchey (2008), ‘Critical theory is about possibility, and hope, and change’ (p. 14). I work and will continue to work to change the world’s perception of Down syndrome. To show Kaleb and the rest of the world that he will not be limited by me and if I can help it, by anyone else. I will strive to look for and create ways to show him the world and find the light so he and others can see the colors of this world.


Cawthon, D. (2002). Philosophical foundations of leadership.  New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

Feinberg, W. (na). The disclosure of philosophy of education. Retrieved from: https://blackboard.cuchicago.edu/bbcswebdav/pid-2135742-dt-content-rid-7777338_2/courses/1683.201710/FPR-7011-Online-Template_ImportedContent_20120504092620/FPR-7010-Online-Template_ImportedContent_20120105102614/Feinberg_The%20Discourse%20of%20Philosophy%20of%20Ed.pdf

Hinchey, P.  (2008). Finding freedom in the classroom: A Practical Introduction to Critical Theory
New York, NY: Peter Lang.

Plato. (1997).  Republic in Plato: complete works.  Indianapolis, Hackett. Retrieved from: https://blackboard.cuchicago.edu/bbcswebdav/pid-2135726-dt-content-rid-7777515_2/courses/1683.201710/Plato_Turning%20the%20Psyche.pdf

Standish, P. (2005). The nature and purposes of education. In A companion to the philosophy of education (p. 221-231). New York: Wiley-Blackwell.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

These Adventures We Call Life: A New Diagnosis

I’ve unpacked most of our luggage from vacation. Laundry and dishwasher are both running. I’m now sitting here in the recliner researching and reading, trying to expand my knowledge on Kaleb’s latest diagnosis. I am reading about cerebral palsy, or more specifically, spastic diplegia CP. The movie Avatar is playing in the background. Why do I mention the movie playing when I have much more on my mind today after Kaleb getting yet another diagnosis added to his seemingly ever growing file? It’s because the choice in movie.
After a few minutes I am reminded as my heart aches from processing this new piece of information that this movie ironically was on the tv on another hard day in my life. That realization, the recall of that memory, and life following suddenly makes it easier to process this new added section to Kaleb’s file. That day was the day after Kaleb’s diagnosis of Down syndrome. It was also our last night in the hospital. I was going to be discharged the following day. TJ an…

Happy birthday: I Love You Stinky Face

Happy birthday Kaleb! Every birthday a person experiences is special but I'm not sure one has held so much significance for me as your first birthday. In some ways I feel that it is my own, since it signifies the beginning of my own transformation.

I think back to this past year filled with all the tears, heartaches, prayers, cuddles, hope, and love. I am reminded of our bedtime story, I Love You Stinky Face. I read it to you each night while you sit on my lap nestled against me. Yes, it's the one that you try to hold and turn the pages while I'm still reading. At least once or twice during the story you will turn your little head to watch me with your big beautiful eyes as I read.
I love that book. It's a very cute story. The other night while rocking you and giving you a few extra cuddles I read the back of the book. The back of the book speaks to the unconditional love of a mother. In the book the mother's love is tested. This year has tested us but I hope you h…

May I Have This Dance

As I spin you in my arms dancing around the living room I look at your beautiful face and you look up smiling at me. It's such a sweet moment, the kind of moment that you want to bottle up and keep forever. As we dance I watch your tiny little hand rest in mine and I lean my head against yours. As we dance I think of dancing with you as you grow throughout the years. Dances with you on my feet while I lead and then dances as you get older and you lead. My train of thought continues drifting the years of your life until the thought of dancing with you at your wedding plays in my mind. That sweet moment I had been enjoying is interrupted and is replaced with frustration and heart ache. You see my precious child I love you so much and it pains me whenever I have a thought and then begin to wonder if you will ever get to experience it. 
Then almost as quickly as the frustration and heart ache appears it disappears and is replaced with feelings of irritation at myself. I work to be to a…